Fanstake Fanstake COLLEGIATE ATHLETICS FOOTBALL WEEK 12 THURSDAY, 11/19
Carter Stimson
P · SO · Elon Phoenix

Carter Stimson

P SO Elon
About Stimson Updated Sep 9, 2026

Carter Stimson is Elon’s high-upside punter with a booming leg and elite high school pedigree

In the 2026 season, redshirt freshman Carter Stimson is competing for Elon’s punting job and has already shown a live leg, including a 42-yard punt in the opener and a 39-yard punt against Davidson. His differentiator is upside: he arrived with a strong resume, including 2024 Kohl’s Kicking First Team All-American honors and a senior-year average of 49 yards per punt, plus a school-record 54-yard field goal in high school. If you want a specialist with proven talent and room to grow, he’s worth watching.

Schedule

0 rated

ATHLETE DNA

2026
FBS median (50th)
Volume
2nd percentile; Full confidence; 10 games
Distance
16th percentile; Full confidence; 10 games
Accuracy
Evidence unavailable; still building
Hangtime
76th percentile; Full confidence; 10 games
Consistency
55th percentile; Full confidence; 10 games

Fair Market Value

$28K

Qualified estimate

History starts here — the trend chart appears once a second snapshot is recorded.

Fan Score

80 Fan Score
Is Stimson's Fan Score too low or too high?

Sign in to vote. One vote per week — you can change it while the window is open.

Career Stats

SEASONSCHOOL
202610