Karsten Stotlar brings a big lefty frame and late-inning value for Western Illinois
Karsten Stotlar is a 6-foot-5 left-hander whose appeal starts with pro-style size, a starter’s look, and bullpen utility. In the 2025 season, he ranked second on Western Illinois in appearances with 21, logged 31.2 innings, struck out 16, and recorded two saves; his current 2026 team stats show a tougher year with a higher ERA, so he profiles more as a leverage arm than a finished product. He has also shown durability and versatility, with prior college experience before WIU and a track record of working in relief. If your team wants a long, physical lefty who can handle pressure innings, he’s worth a look.
