Big-time lefty upside, but 2026 is on ice
In the 2025 season, McCoy showed why evaluators loved the arm: he worked 60 innings with 77 strikeouts for South Carolina and was once viewed as a potential Friday-night anchor and top-100 MLB Draft talent. The separator is pure left-handed velocity and bat-missing stuff, but the caution light is real—he’s coming off UCL surgery and will miss the 2026 season. If you want a high-upside, high-variance arm with ace traits when healthy, McCoy is absolutely worth caring about.
