Paige Lillie brings two-way upside and high-end makeup to Butler
Paige Lillie is a versatile Butler pitcher/infielder from Hortonville, Wisconsin who arrived with a strong reputation as a power arm and an all-around athlete, plus top-tier academic credentials. Butler’s 2024 signing release highlighted her as a power pitcher who can also help in the infield and at the plate, while the 2026 preview listed her among the Bulldogs’ experienced returnees on the dirt. For a coach, that’s the appeal: multi-position flexibility, competitive three-sport background, and a player profile that suggests steady upside rather than flashy empty stats.
