Kelli Plumaker gives Niagara a real pinch-hit pop threat
Plumaker is a compact 5-3 C/OF who already showed she can change a game, including a pinch-hit home run against Marist in Niagara’s 2026 series. Her profile suggests value more as a spark than a volume stat collector: she brings offensive upside, roster flexibility behind the plate and in the outfield, and a high-effort, multi-sport athletic background from Saint John Vianney. For a team, she looks like a useful depth piece with situational power and versatility rather than a proven everyday centerpiece.