Fanstake Fanstake COLLEGIATE ATHLETICS FOOTBALL WEEK 9 MONDAY, 10/26
James Wagenseller
P · SR · Army West Point Black Knights

James Wagenseller

P SR Army
About Wagenseller Updated Aug 15, 2026

Army’s steady-legged punter with top-end leg strength

James Wagenseller was Army’s starting punter in the 2025 season, averaging 43.1 yards on 32 punts with 13 kicks inside the 20 and just two touchbacks, after a 2024 season of 41.7 yards on 24 punts with zero blocks. He brings a big frame at 6-foot-3, 225 pounds and a reliable, field-position-first style that fits Army’s grind-it-out identity; the appeal is consistency, hang time, and enough leg to flip the field, not flashy volume. He looks like a strong fit for teams that value disciplined special teams and hidden-yardage wins.

Schedule

0 rated

DNA

Early season — still building Updated Oct 26, 2026
Wagenseller National punter Average
Volume
~22nd percentile; Building confidence; 7 games
Distance
~71st percentile; Building confidence; 7 games
Accuracy
Evidence unavailable; still building
Hangtime
~60th percentile; Building confidence; 7 games
Consistency
~26th percentile; Building confidence; 7 games

Fair Market Value

$47K

Qualified estimate

Fan Score

80 Fan Score
Is Wagenseller's Fan Score too low or too high?

Sign in to vote. One vote per week — you can change it while the window is open.

Career Stats

SEASONSCHOOL
20267
202511
202411