Fanstake Fanstake COLLEGIATE ATHLETICS FOOTBALL WEEK 12 THURSDAY, 11/19
Toby Payne
TE · SR · Marshall Thundering Herd

Toby Payne

TE SR Marshall
About Payne Updated Jul 22, 2026

Toby Payne is a productive, reliable Marshall TE with proven red-zone value

Payne has been a steady, efficient contributor for Marshall, with 34 career catches for 362 yards and 9 touchdowns, and he showed real usefulness in 2024 with 17 receptions for 168 yards over 13 games. He profiles as a dependable tight end rather than a flashy volume producer: his value is in getting open, finishing drives, and giving an offense a trustworthy middle-of-the-field target. At 6'4" and 237 pounds, he brings the size to fit a physical scheme, and his recent usage suggests a coach can lean on him in key spots.

Schedule

0 rated

ATHLETE DNA

Production Big plays Reliability FBS median (50th)
Receiving Production
34th percentile; Full confidence; 10 games
Usage
58th percentile; Full confidence; 10 games / 10 PBP
Big Play
4th percentile; Full confidence; 10 games
Scoring Threat
8th percentile; Full confidence; 10 games / 10 PBP
Reliability
44th percentile; Full confidence; 10 games
Playmaker
8th percentile; Full confidence; 10 games
Clutch
14th percentile; Full confidence; 10 games / 10 PBP
Consistency
15th percentile; Full confidence; 10 games

Fair Market Value

$243K

▼ $22K this month

Qualified estimate

Stats

2026

Percentile among FBS TEs — a longer bar ranks higher

272
Receiving Yards
52nd of 481 TEs
0
Receiving Touchdowns
238th of 481 TEs
32
Receptions
24th of 481 TEs
8.5
Yards per Catch
110th of 147 TEs
3
Rushing Yards
27th of 54 TEs
0
Rushing Touchdowns
18th of 54 TEs
1
Rushing Attempts
27th of 54 TEs
Career Stats
SEASONSCHOOL
202693227208.5
20251237393310.6
2024121716869.9
202210227113.5
Rivals Football

We’ve got college fantasy football. Go head-to-head with a rival fan every game day.

Fan Score

80 Fan Score
Is Payne's Fan Score too low or too high?

Sign in to vote. One vote per week — you can change it while the window is open.