Manhattan’s innings-eating RHP with strikeout upside, but command remains the swing skill
In the 2026 season, Andrew Castelluccio has been a volume arm for Manhattan, throwing 16.2 innings with 11 strikeouts, but his 10.80 ERA and 15 walks show that strike-throwing is the biggest separator between his potential and his current results.[1][6][8] The right-hander has the frame and prior recruiting pedigree to project as a durable bullpen or starter option, and his 2022 showcase reports noted a mid-80s fastball with breaking-ball potential.[2][7] He looks like a fit for a staff that values size, development runway, and pitcher upside more than immediate polish.[5][7]
