Reserve Guard Returning From Injury at St. John Fisher
McCarthy’s current value is mostly about upside and toughness: in 2024-25 he appeared in eight games and scored seven points in a win over Elmira, and he missed the 2025-26 season due to injury, so the picture is more “health check” than stat-sheet stardom right now.[2] He’s the kind of low-usage guard teams monitor for reliability, depth, and a chance to re-enter the rotation if he gets back to full strength; the key differentiator is whether his injury setback has fully cleared, because that will determine if he can become a steady, hard-nosed backcourt piece.[2]
