Fanstake Fanstake COLLEGIATE ATHLETICS FOOTBALL WEEK 3 FRIDAY, 9/18
Peter Costelli
QB · SR · Middle Tennessee Blue Raiders

Peter Costelli

QB SR Middle Tennessee
About Costelli Updated Sep 11, 2026

Peter Costelli brings veteran transfer experience and dual-threat juice to Middle Tennessee

Costelli enters the 2026 season as a graduate-transfer QB at Middle Tennessee, bringing a sturdy 6-foot-3, 234-pound frame, former four-star pedigree, and some sneaky mobility to the Blue Raiders’ quarterback room[1][3][7]. In 2025 at Northern Colorado, he appeared in four games and posted 272 passing yards, 1 passing TD, 4 interceptions, plus 74 rushing yards and 1 rushing TD, which says he can create off-script but still needs cleaner decision-making[1][2][6]. The appeal: experienced, tough, and physically pro-ready; the caution flag: he’s still more “developmental stopgap with upside” than finished product[1][7][14].

Schedule

0 rated

DNA

Limited data for this season 2025 season · Updated Sep 8, 2026
Costelli Natl avg · QBs

Similar DNA · past 20 years

Tap a player to overlay their DNA on the chart

Comparison candidates aren't available for this profile yet.

Accuracy
~31st percentile; Building confidence; 4 games
Mobility
~51st percentile; Building confidence; 4 games
Decision-Making
~26th percentile; Building confidence; 4 games
Playmaker
~33rd percentile; Building confidence; 4 games
Efficiency
~26th percentile; Building confidence; 4 games
Leadership
~44th percentile; Thin sample; 4 games / 0 PBP
Consistency
~33rd percentile; Building confidence; 4 games
Deep Ball
~33rd percentile; Building confidence; 4 games
Clutch
~50th percentile; Thin sample; 4 games / 0 PBP

Fair Market Value

Not enough data to calculate

History starts here — the trend chart appears once a second snapshot is recorded.

Stats

2026

No stats are available for this season.

Career Stats
SEASONSCHOOL
20260-----
2025456.4%27214102.9
2024554.2%59142135.9

Fan Score

Fan Score
Costelli's Fan Score is building.

Voting opens when a score is available.