Kelcie McGraw has become Colgate’s ace-in-the-making
In the 2026 season, first-year pitcher Kelcie McGraw emerged as one of Colgate’s most important arms, leading the team with 14 wins, logging 11 complete games, three shutouts and three saves across 132.0 innings, while striking out at least five in her last three starts and peaking with an 11-strikeout, 10-inning gem against Army.[15] She earned Patriot League Pitcher of the Week honors after a 3–0 week with a save and a 1.40 ERA, which says a lot about her poise, workload and late-season competitiveness.[5] If you want a pitcher who can handle big innings, finish games, and bring some bulldog energy to the circle, she looks like a strong fit.[15][5]
