Joey Tonnotti’s bullpen arrow is pointing up at Saint Peter’s
In the 2026 season, Joey Tonnotti has flashed legit relief value for Saint Peter’s, highlighted by a four-inning, no-hit, four-strikeout outing against Siena that shows he can miss bats and hold games in place when he’s on.[6] He’s a right-handed pitcher with a starter’s mentality out of the bullpen, and his profile suggests a competitive arm with some upside from a strong prep pedigree at IMG Academy and USA Baseball NTDP experience.[1][12] The fit is intriguing if you want a live, strikeout-capable arm who can handle leverage, though his season has also included some rougher outings, so consistency is the big swing skill.