Fanstake Fanstake COLLEGIATE ATHLETICS FOOTBALL WEEK 12 TUESDAY, 11/17
Colby McCalister
S · SR · Baylor Bears

Colby McCalister

S SR Baylor
About McCalister Updated Aug 23, 2026

Steady, Physical Kansas State Safety with Real Starting Experience

In the 2024 season, Colby McCalister showed up as a reliable Kansas State safety with 24 tackles, and his broader Wildcat résumé includes 50 career tackles, two pass breakups, one sack, and one forced fumble across 26 games. The biggest selling points are his versatility, toughness, and experience in a disciplined Big 12 defense; he’s the kind of safety who brings structure, effort, and enough thump to matter in the box. He also played through a shoulder issue in 2025, which adds a little grit to the profile.

Schedule

0 rated

ATHLETE DNA

Coverage Tackling Big moments FBS median (50th)
Tackling
41st percentile; Full confidence; 9 games
Coverage
38th percentile; Full confidence; 9 games
Ball Hawk
26th percentile; Full confidence; 9 games
Disruption
23rd percentile; Thin sample; 9 games / 0 PBP
Playmaker
34th percentile; Full confidence; 9 games
Turnover Creator
21st percentile; Thin sample; 9 games / 0 PBP
Production
37th percentile; Thin sample; 9 games / 0 PBP
Consistency
51st percentile; Full confidence; 9 games
Clutch
37th percentile; Full confidence; 9 games / 9 PBP

Fair Market Value

$281K

Qualified estimate

Stats

2026

Percentile among FBS DBs — a longer bar ranks higher

26
Tackles
595th of 1,973 DBs
21
Solo Tackles
364th of 1,973 DBs
5
Assisted Tackles
904th of 1,973 DBs
2
Passes Defended
464th of 1,973 DBs
0
Sacks
210th of 1,973 DBs
Career Stats
SEASONSCHOOL
20269262152
202411231581
202313272341

Fan Score

80 Fan Score
Is McCalister's Fan Score too low or too high?

Sign in to vote. One vote per week — you can change it while the window is open.