Versatile Villanova INF with a high-contact, on-base profile
Toole has been a steady, multi-position infield piece for Villanova, splitting time across first, third, and second while showing a knack for getting on base and drawing contact rather than just hunting power. In 2025, he hit .226 with a .377 OBP, added seven walks and eight hit-by-pitches, and posted a seven-game hitting streak, which points to a disciplined, tough at-bat profile that coaches value. He looks like a fit for teams that want defensive flexibility, competitiveness, and a grinder mentality more than pure slugging.[1][7][5]