Fanstake Fanstake COLLEGIATE ATHLETICS FOOTBALL WEEK 9 MONDAY, 10/26
McCae Hillstead
QB · JR · Utah State Aggies

McCae Hillstead

QB JR Utah State
About Hillstead Updated Jul 26, 2026

undersized, mobile QB with starting experience and upside

Hillstead is a **small-but-competitive dual-threat quarterback** whose appeal comes from his live arm, mobility, and real game reps: in the **2023 season** at Utah State, he threw for **1,062 yards, 11 TDs, and 8 INTs** while adding **36 rushing yards** across 8 games. [2] He’s listed at **5-foot-10, 190 pounds** and is now with **BYU**, where reports have described him as a potential contender for the job if the depth chart opens up. [1][7] The fit is best for a team that values quick decision-making, playmaking outside structure, and a quarterback who can win with toughness and tempo more than prototype size. [1][5]

Schedule

DNA

2023
Established Updated Oct 19, 2026
Hillstead National QB Average
Accuracy
34th percentile; Full confidence; 8 games
Mobility
25th percentile; Full confidence; 8 games
Decision-Making
3rd percentile; Full confidence; 8 games
Playmaker
23rd percentile; Full confidence; 8 games
Efficiency
24th percentile; Full confidence; 8 games
Leadership
36th percentile; Full confidence; 8 games / 8 PBP
Consistency
73rd percentile; Full confidence; 8 games
Deep Ball
48th percentile; Full confidence; 8 games
Clutch
17th percentile; Full confidence; 8 games / 8 PBP

Fair Market Value

$744K

Qualified estimate

Stats

2026

Percentile among FBS QBs — a longer bar ranks higher

93.2
Passer Rating
166th of 169 QBs
225
Passing Yards
192nd of 367 QBs
2
Passing Touchdowns
168th of 367 QBs
4
Interceptions
283rd of 367 QBs
45.9%
%Completions
169th of 169 QBs
6.1
Yards per Attempt
150th of 169 QBs
17
Completions
196th of 367 QBs
37
Passing Attempts
190th of 367 QBs
53
Rushing Yards
142nd of 368 QBs
0
Rushing Touchdowns
186th of 368 QBs
Career Stats
SEASONSCHOOL
2026245.9%2252493.2
2025480%3300135.4
2023859.5%1062118128.8

Fan Score

80 Fan Score
Is Hillstead's Fan Score too low or too high?

Sign in to vote. One vote per week — you can change it while the window is open.