Fanstake Fanstake COLLEGIATE ATHLETICS FOOTBALL WEEK 9 FRIDAY, 10/30
Trey Mitchell
QB · SO · ETSU Buccaneers

Trey Mitchell

QB SO East Tennessee State
About Mitchell Updated May 11, 2026

ETSU QB Trey Mitchell: Solid 2019 Starter, But Pro Potential Faded Post-College

Trey Mitchell shone as ETSU Buccaneers' QB in 2019, completing 148-of-265 passes (55.8% rate, 6th in program history) for 1,616 yards and 11 TDs across 12 games with 11 straight starts, showcasing pocket poise and leadership under pressure. His dual-threat accuracy and resilience stood out in a run-heavy offense, but limited arm strength and no notable stats since suggest he's transitioned away from football—perhaps to strength sports. Great for developmental teams valuing intangibles, but not an NFL fit without recent tape.

Schedule

DNA

2019
Updated Oct 19, 2026
Mitchell National QB Average
Accuracy
29th percentile; Full confidence; 12 games
Mobility
9th percentile; Full confidence; 12 games
Decision-Making
61st percentile; Full confidence; 12 games
Playmaker
49th percentile; Full confidence; 12 games
Efficiency
22nd percentile; Full confidence; 12 games
Leadership
Evidence unavailable; still building
Consistency
49th percentile; Full confidence; 12 games
Deep Ball
55th percentile; Full confidence; 12 games
Clutch
~50th percentile; Thin sample; No clutch opportunities

Stats

2019

Percentile among FCS QBs — a longer bar ranks higher

116.2
Passer Rating
106th of 151 QBs
1616
Passing Yards
97th of 355 QBs
11
Passing Touchdowns
94th of 355 QBs
6
Interceptions
250th of 355 QBs
55.8%
%Completions
107th of 151 QBs
6.1
Yards per Attempt
115th of 151 QBs
148
Completions
85th of 355 QBs
265
Passing Attempts
86th of 355 QBs
-22
Rushing Yards
325th of 356 QBs
1
Rushing Touchdowns
121st of 356 QBs
Career Stats
SEASONSCHOOL
20191255.8%1616116116.2

Fan Score

— Fan Score
Mitchell's Fan Score is building.

Voting opens when a score is available.