Garrett Theile is Manhattan’s late-inning clean-up arm
In the 2026 season, Garrett Theile has shown value as a leverage reliever for Manhattan, earning a save on April 7 and another on April 18, then covering three innings with two strikeouts against Canisius on April 26. Theile’s appeal is less about flashy volume and more about composure: he’s been trusted to finish games, escape jams, and keep the Jaspers alive in tight spots. If your team wants a right-hander who competes with poise in pressure innings, he’s a fit.
