Tulsa’s Quiet Kicker: Experienced, Accurate in Prep, Still Waiting for Game-Day Proof
Evan Guenthner is a redshirt junior placekicker at Tulsa with a low-profile but interesting background: he was a high-school specialist who went 43-for-43 on PATs and connected on 5-of-8 field goals as a senior in 2022, but he has yet to log game action in college at Tulsa through the 2025 season. His appeal is projection and steadiness rather than production right now — a walk-on with academic recognition, a solid build for a kicker, and the kind of clean-footed prep résumé that suggests reliability if he earns the job. For a team, he looks like a developmental depth piece, not a proven plug-and-play answer.
