Garrett McGuire gives Mercyhurst a steady leg with room to climb
In the 2025 season, Garrett McGuire handled 39 punts for Mercyhurst, averaging 37.4 yards with a long of 52 and 7 kicks downed inside the 20, showing useful field-position control even if the raw average is still developing. He’s a local product from Erie and a former all-conference high school standout, which fits the profile of a dependable specialist who knows the region and the pressure. The upside here is consistency and touch, not fireworks—he looks like a solid fit for a team that values situational punting and hidden-yardage battles.
